Image source, Courtesy of Lorena Laya
Warning: certain descriptions may affect the sensitivity of readers.
Lorena Laya distrusted her hunches. He had decided to stick to science and undergo DNA testing to avoid the pain of seeing one corpse after another, feeling unable to recognize his brother Diego or his father Henry.
By that time he had recovered the bodies of his stepmother, Nohelia Iriarte, 45, and his "little sister" Giannys Laya, 6, who had been buried after the two earthquakes on June 24 in La Guaira, in northern Venezuela.
The Laya Iriarte family lived in OPPPE 27, acronym for the Presidential Office of Special Plans and Projects during the government of Hugo Chávez, the body that had built those 12-story towers in Caraballeda and which has been questioned for not having ordered previous soil quality studies.
On Monday, July 20, the day Diego would have turned 15, Lorena reported her brother and father as missing to the Venezuelan scientific police and interviewed experts from the National Service of Medicine and Forensic Sciences (Senamecf), the organization that manages the identification of earthquake victims.
Three days later, he took his grandfather from La Guaira to Caracas to have blood samples taken for genetic analysis in a Senamecf laboratory.
That day, during the extraction, Lorena received a WhatsApp message from her girlfriend, Yemily Beomón: "We took out the body. They say it is Diego. I'm washing it and I'm here taking care of it so they don't take it away until you come."
"I'm not sure"
Two weeks before, Lorena herself had gone under the ruins through a kind of rubble tunnel that the neighbors had managed to open with their own hands, to verify if the rest of a leg they had found belonged to her brother's body.
End of Most read
All the news you need is on BBC World Service
Download it here
End of Ad app
But it was so dark and there was so much dust that after looking closely at the knee, calf, and flip-flop lying next to the bare foot, he did not dare confirm that it was Diego, a tall, thin teenager who had no tattoos or marks that would allow him to be distinguished at a glance.
"The corpse was complete, all its bones, it had clothing and it had a little hair and skin left on its fingers," says Lorena. "I wasn't sure it was him, although my brother's maternal uncles were."
There was one day left until the first month of the earthquakes had passed.
"I can't put in the bag of this body that it is 100% my brother because I'm really not sure," Lorena told the uncles and Yemily, who had helped remove the body with surgical gloves and tools that she had obtained herself, given that the crane that was removing the debris had been paralyzed for two weeks due to a failure.
"I'm going to take it. I'm going to ask the anthropologists to look at it, for the dentist to look at it," Lorena remembers telling her relatives, confident that the resin work her brother had on his upper teeth would make identification easier.
Lorena did not want to disappoint Diego's maternal uncles, who had dug into the ruins every day without rest and had been her support in the moments of greatest anguish.
"Let's see, they are the experts. They are going to determine 100% if it is him or not."
"I had to carry them"
Just as she did with the bodies of her stepmother and her little sister, Lorena claims that she herself carried what could have been Diego's with an uncle of her brother. Then they put him in a truck and took him to Los Silos.
"I had to carry them together with another person, either because one of the two officials did not want to carry them - they normally went in pairs - or because they did not have gloves or because they were simply disgusted."
Los Silos is a facility in the port of La Guaira originally intended to store grain, but after the earthquakes it ended up being converted into an improvised morgue where the rescued bodies arrived.
"I frequently went to Los Silos to see photos of corpses and enter my father's and my brother's IDs into a system they have there. Some corpses that still had skin had their fingerprints taken and compared with that of the SAIME," explains Lorena in reference to the records of the Venezuelan identification service.
In an effort to avoid the possibility that her brother and father would never appear, Lorena had set herself the task of seeing bodies to avoid trauma to the rest of her family.
"For all of us who had to experience this firsthand, it was very cruel. Let's say it took away our innocence," says the 25-year-old. "I don't want other people to experience this."
"It wasn't him"
Upon arriving at Los Silos, Lorena remembers that the authorities assigned a number to the body. "I was quite attentive to the number, because I had already been through it with my sister and I already knew more or less how things worked. I kept the number before they took it."
Lorena says that she notified her doubt that it was Diego's body and asked for experts to examine it. He remembers waiting between 30 to 40 minutes until they brought the body back.
"He came in a bag that we had put for him, but they put another one there; then they removed both bags, opened them." Lorena claims that a dentist and a forensic anthropologist took her data and asked for information about Diego.
"I emphasized to the dentist the issue of my brother's teeth. I even made him listen to the voice notes of the dentist who treated him," says Lorena.
"She opened his jaw, she even took out the two teeth from the skull and checked them. I even saw them like that, in her hand."
Lorena assures that, although the corpse no longer had skin on its face, it had some on its fingers. "I was there next to them, next to the body, while they were touching it and checking it, examining it."
The experts said that the body did not have the resin that Lorena was referring to on Diego's upper teeth. "The same dentist told me that that person had wear on his teeth for quite some time, which did not match someone so young, 14 years old."
The anthropologist confirmed that it was "an adult person who had already finished growing, who was not him."
Lorena left Los Silos "disappointed." When he communicated the results of the forensic evaluation to Diego's uncles, they insisted that they had found him and that it was his body.
"I told them, 'This was the explanation they gave me. We have to believe. These are the only tools we have.'"
"Like a crime scene"
International disaster victim identification protocols are designed to prevent family members from being exposed to indiscriminate identification of bodies, explains Andreas Kleiser, Director of Policy and Cooperation at the International Commission on Missing Persons (ICMP).
This intergovernmental organization assists the authorities of countries experiencing natural disasters or armed conflicts in the search for missing persons.
“From a human rights perspective, families should not be left alone in this task,” Kleiser says in a video call from ICMP headquarters in The Hague, Netherlands.
"It is essential to protect families in these situations. Visual identification of human remains carries a high risk and two-thirds of these identifications are usually erroneous."
From the authorities' perspective, Kleiser warns that it is necessary to "ensure data protection" during identification processes and "be aware of unexpected discrepancies in biological links that may arise during forensic analysis."
"There is a responsibility on the part of the State, which has the obligation to maintain or guarantee the necessary capacity to help in these cases, as well as to train personnel to carry out these tasks."
Based on other experiences, such as the underwater earthquake in the Indian Ocean that caused a devastating tsunami in Southeast Asia in 2004, Kleiser assures that the recovery of victims begins with the removal of debris.
"It is necessary to decontaminate the places, since in these structures there are numerous contaminants that mix with the debris." For this reason, families should not go into fallen buildings, as is the case in La Guaira.
Image source, Courtesy of the International Commission on Missing Persons
"In a disaster like this you don't necessarily treat every building as a crime scene, that's debatable. But in many scenarios you have to treat everything as a crime scene."
Although he acknowledged that it is very difficult to be prepared to respond to devastation like the one left by the earthquakes in Venezuela, "it all depends on who faces the situation and the resources at their disposal."
"I'm so sorry this young woman had to go through this," says Kleiser upon learning Lorena's story. "I also regret that the authorities did not have the necessary equipment to deal with such a situation."
In parallel with the recovery of the bodies, the expert assures that it is vital "to have a reliable record of the victims."
"Both for official record purposes and for reasons of commemoration and dignity, it is a task that must be initiated and addressed independently of the arduous task of recovering the remains."
Last August, the Venezuelan government reported 6,301 deaths in the earthquakes and so far has not offered an estimate of the missing.
Kleiser says that the ICMP contacted the Delcy Rodríguez government to provide its expertise, but never received a response.
The BBC asked the Venezuelan government for comment but received no response.
image source, Reuters
The fingerprint
Two weeks after the authorities ruled out that the body was that of Diego, Lorena returned to Los Silos to check, with the ID numbers of her brother and father, if the fingerprints of any corpse matched those of her relatives.
"They tell me: 'Yes, there is a match with your brother's ID, it is the number of such and such a body.' And I had written down the number that they gave to that body that I brought and that they told me was not my brother."
Lorena checked her cell phone and discovered that it was the same number.
"I tell him: 'It can't be possible, because I brought the number you're telling me myself, I myself witnessed how they checked it in detail, they asked me things about my brother and they told me that it wasn't because of his age, that it wasn't because of his teeth.'"
Lorena remembers that the Senamecf official responded: "Well, but the one who shows up by fingerprint is him."
Disoriented by the news, Lorena asked if the body remained in the refrigerated containers of Los Silos. But they told him that he was no longer there. He had been buried in the La Esperanza cemetery in La Guaira, where most of the bodies recovered after the earthquakes were buried.
They recommended that Lorena go to the Senamecf headquarters in Caracas to ask them to compare the DNA of the samples they had taken from her and her grandfather with those from the body.
"When I presented this case in Bello Monte (the headquarters in Caracas) was when they found out about this 'anomaly,'" says Lorena.
BBC Mundo contacted Senamecf to consult the case but did not receive a response.
"I felt guilty. Could it be that he was my brother?" he still wonders. "In the midst of my attempt to be rational, to think with my head and not with my heart, I let my brother go and it was really him?"
Almost five months after the earthquakes, Lorena Laya is still waiting for the results of the DNA analysis to find out if Diego has already been buried in La Esperanza or is still one of those missing from the La Guaira earthquakes.
Discover more
Video
End of Video




