The day after the launch of the Israeli-American operation on Iran, which notably led to the death of Supreme Guide Ali Khamenei, Thierry Coville, researcher at Iris and specialist in Iran, analyzes the justifications and legality of such an attack from the point of view of international law, as well as the "very worrying scenario which is looming" in the region.
Published on: 01/03/2026 - 15:11
If many observers rejoice at the death of Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, the cornerstone of the mullahs' regime in Iran, the strikes carried out by Israel and the United States against Iran are nevertheless denounced by several countries and political figures, who denounce the non-compliance with international law.
“We reject the unilateral military action of the United States and Israel, which represents an escalation and contributes to making the international order more uncertain and hostile,” wrote Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez on
“The death of Ali Khamenei, executioner of the Iranian people, does not justify the means which caused it. Kidnapping or assassinating the leaders whose policies we are fighting remains the negation of all international law,” he wrote on the X platform, believing that the war being waged is the “supremacist will of Trump and Netanyahu”.
Allies of Iran, China and Russia also reacted on Sunday March 1. Russian President Vladimir Putin called the elimination of Ali Khamenei a “cynical violation” of “morality and international law.” This death constitutes “a serious violation of the sovereignty and security of Iran, the objectives and principles of the Charter of the United Nations and the fundamental norms of international relations”, indicated the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
International law, political objective, human cost... interviewed by France 24, Thierry Coville, researcher at Iris, specialist in Iran and author of the work "Iran. The invisible revolution" (ed. La Découverte), takes stock of the justifications and legality of such an operation.
France 24: Is the Israeli-American operation in Iran surprising?
Thierry Coville: We are disconcerted by the acceleration of History, it is the scenario that everyone feared. We must remember that we are reliving what we have already experienced in June 2025, since Iran and the United States were in negotiations on the nuclear issue. I am a little surprised when I hear that Iran represents a threat to the Israelis because of its pursuit of the atomic bomb, since since June 2025, they have stopped enriching uranium. In negotiations with the United States, Iran proposed suspending uranium enrichment for the remainder of Trump's term, and then requested the right to enrich uranium at a civilian level, under IAEA control.
Once again, it is a trampling, a total disregard for international law, since to attack, Trump said that he did not want Iran to acquire the atomic bomb. But since Iran no longer enriches uranium, how can this attack be justifiable under international law?
As for the Israeli justification: in June, they had already attacked Iran by saying that it was preparing the atomic bomb, which was false according to all the secret services in the world. Now they say it's the ballistics program that's their problem.
It is therefore a total disregard for international law, and it is a bit of a disaster scenario: there are already many civilian victims in Iran. We knew that Tehran was going to respond. We see that the destruction of the country is beginning, with a power that does not want to give in.
What is the political objective of all this? If the objective is regime change, then indeed we are moving towards something very costly, perhaps for the Israelis and the Americans, but especially for the Iranians, with civilian casualties. Democracy, but at what human cost? This is a very worrying scenario that is looming.
By saying nothing, we are in a situation, like currently, where any country can attack any other country, all you have to do is invent a pretext.
However, negotiations between the United States and Iran took place earlier this week in Geneva. Were these facade negotiations?
In his press release, Emmanuel Macron advises the Americans and the Iranians to continue to negotiate, but that is still three times that Donald Trump has stabbed [Iran] in the back: in May 2018, when he left the nuclear agreement – which the Iranians respected –; in June 2025, when he lets Netanyahu attack Iran, while he is negotiating with Iran and a new negotiation is planned; and there, recently, when there was progress in the negotiations, Iran having proposed to suspend uranium enrichment for a limited period.
We are therefore beginning to say that all this is ultimately just a pretext, and that the ultimate desire of the Israelis and the Americans is a change of regime in Iran. But in this case, for what political objective? We don't know anything about that.
We are promised a democracy, but I think we are sold a lot of dreams.
The Western camp says it defends the values of human rights and respect for international law, but the civilians who are currently dying are considered collateral damage. The way we act is important, especially for Europeans, and today, we can regret their silence.
The Revolutionary Guards promise the “fierceest response in history”. Is this rhetoric or do they really have the means?
It is Iran's logic to always be in one-upmanship. When the Europeans threatened to reinstate UN sanctions against Iran [the snapback process], Tehran threatened to leave the non-proliferation treaty – which would have been catastrophic. This would have meant that he was, indeed, heading towards the nuclear bomb. There is indeed a tendency among the Iranians to outbid and bluff.
There, I think we have changed paradigm. I don't have the answer to the question, but I see that on the Iranian side, they had warned: if they believe that their vital interests are at stake and that we want to put an end to the regime, they can consider for their part that all attempts are permitted, hence their desire now to regionalize the conflict. And that's really very dangerous.
Keywords associated with the article
The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.




