image copyrightGetty Images

U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin plan to hold a tripartite meeting in Shenzhen on Thursday (November 19). This is the first face-to-face meeting between the leaders of the three countries in history.

Based on information from all parties, the meeting will be held at Qilin Villa in Shenzhen, and local security has been significantly strengthened before the meeting. This government reception building complex is backed by Qilin Mountain and adjacent to Xili Lake. It is not as well-known as the Diaoyutai State Guesthouse in Beijing.

Qilin Villa is about a 30-minute drive from the main APEC venue. It is surrounded by mountains on three sides and faces water on one side. It has good sealing and security conditions. It also has ties to Xi Jinping’s father, Xi Zhongxun, and hosted late North Korean leader Kim Jong Il.

Experts believe that Beijing chose this place because it wanted to position the meeting as a sideline arrangement during APEC, rather than a separate high-profile summit. In a diplomatic setting, the meeting place itself is a message.

Why Qilin Villa?

Qilin Villa is a state-owned building complex that was opened in 1997 and has long been used to receive Chinese leaders and visiting foreign guests. It is different from a commercially operated five-star hotel. It covers an area of ​​more than 300,000 square meters and is hidden between lychee forests and lakes and mountains.

In a closed park consisting of multiple independent villas, it is relatively easy to arrange security. It is also not far from the airport, and Trump can leave directly after the meeting.

Dr. Minseon Ku of DePaul University’s Grace School of Applied Diplomacy specializes in summit diplomacy. She said the choice showed Beijing wanted this to be more like sideline talks during APEC. "Because as the host of the APEC summit, Xi Jinping hopes that the summit will become the main event and does not want the trilateral meeting to overshadow it."

Yuan Shaoyu, a professor at the Center for Global Affairs at New York University who studies Sino-US diplomacy, has a similar view. He told the BBC: "The etiquette here is lighter than in formal venues in Beijing, and the meeting of about an hour is considered to be of a working nature. The lighter the etiquette, the lower the political cost when no results are achieved."

End of Hot Reading

Both Xi Zhongxun and Kim Jong Il have stayed at

Qilin Villa is related to Xi Jinping’s family memory. Xi Zhongxun came to power in Guangdong in the late 1970s and urged the central government to establish a special economic zone in Shenzhen. He is regarded as one of the pioneers of China's reform and opening up.

After retiring to the second line in 1990, he chose to spend his remaining years in Shenzhen. The official media quoted the "Biography of Xi Zhongxun" as reporting that he once went to Qilin Villa and other places to recuperate and take a walk on the advice of his doctor, and said he "liked these places very much."

This place also left a mark in China’s diplomatic history. In January 2006, Kim Jong Il took a special train for an unofficial visit to China, traveling south to inspect special economic zones. According to media reports at the time, after arriving in Shenzhen from Zhuhai, he stayed at Qilin Villa.

Kim Jong Il visited Huawei and other high-tech companies in Shenzhen. That highly confidential reception also tested Qilin Villa's ability to handle high-security guests.

Level of Beijing Diplomatic Field

In modern diplomacy, the location of a meeting reflects the strength of the bilateral relationship, the nature of the visit and the intentions of the host. Yuan Shaoyu said: "State visits have a set of fixed etiquette, and there is very little room for choice of venue. Meetings during multilateral meetings do not have this set of etiquette requirements. The host has much greater room for choice, and the location itself can better illustrate the host's intentions."

There is a clear division of labor in Beijing. The highest-level state visit is indispensable without the red carpet, gun salute and honor guard in Tiananmen Square, and formal talks are arranged in the Great Hall of the People. This centrally located building combines neoclassical and Soviet styles and represents state-level courtesy.

Diaoyutai State Guesthouse was originally a royal garden of the Qing Dynasty and opened in 1959. It is the core place for foreign heads of state to stay and hold important talks. Koo Min-sun said that it is mostly used for working visits and substantive talks. It also has national-level security and protocol standards, but it has the tranquility of a garden than the Great Hall of the People.

Zhongnanhai is even more special. Yuan Shaoyu said: "Zhongnanhai is where the top leaders work and is rarely open to foreign guests. The number of people meeting there is smaller and the conversations are more direct. Being invited in itself expresses the personal trust between leaders." In November 2014, Xi Jinping and then US President Barack Obama had a "night chat" and strolled in Yingtai, Zhongnanhai. The meeting, originally scheduled for less than three hours, actually lasted about five hours. The outside world later regarded it as an example of the "no-tie" diplomacy between the Chinese and US presidents.

In May this year, Trump visited Beijing and had a small-scale meeting and tea with Xi Jinping in Zhongnanhai. Trump asked Xi Jinping in a garden if he had received other foreign leaders here. Xi Jinping replied "very rarely" and added "like Putin."

"Informal" occasions for the President of the United States

The United States also knows how to use the venue. In Washington, the Oval Office, State Dining Room and East Room are the venues for regular bilateral meetings and state banquets. But U.S. presidents often move their meetings outside the White House to create an informal atmosphere. This is sometimes done to bring personal distance, sometimes just for safety and travel reasons.

Camp David in the mountains of Maryland is a prime example. From Franklin D. Roosevelt and Winston Churchill during World War II to the Camp David Accords that led to peace between Egypt and Israel in 1978, this naval retreat has witnessed many meetings away from the media.

Koo Min-sun said: "As the president's private vacation residence, holding a summit at Camp David means that there is a certain degree of friendship between countries and governments, or a closer personal relationship between leaders." She added that when it comes to difficult negotiations, the president may prefer to treat the Camp David meeting as a less official meeting, and it is a secluded place that can minimize the presence of the media. In August 2023, then-President Joe Biden invited Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida and South Korean President Yoon Seok-yue to hold a trilateral summit here. The three countries issued the "Camp David Spirit" statement.

Trump took the approach in a more personal direction during his first term as president, often hosting foreign dignitaries at his private club Mar-a-Lago in Florida. In April 2017, Xi Jinping met Trump for the first time there. Trump said that while the two ate "the most beautiful chocolate cake," he told Xi Jinping about the U.S. air strikes in Syria and had his granddaughter sing a Mandarin song.

In November 2023, while attending the APEC meeting in San Francisco, Biden and Xi Jinping chose Filoli Manor, about 40 kilometers away from the city, to meet for four hours. It is often used for weddings, which not only avoids the noise and demonstrations in the city center, but also adds a pastoral atmosphere to the tense Sino-US relations.

According to interviewed experts, the location selection for summit meetings is usually a long and detailed diplomatic game. When holding side talks at multilateral conferences such as the G20 or APEC, most hosts will give priority to state hotels or historical manors that are within driving distance of the main venue, can be fully enclosed for security, and have a private environment. The security departments of each party often negotiate months in advance on the site's commanding heights, communications, medical access, and even the shape of the negotiation table to avoid any party being at a spatial disadvantage.

When the motorcades of the leaders of the three countries drive into this southern garden, Kirin Villa will once again stand on the stage of history and become the place where the leaders of the three nuclear-armed powers in the world meet for the first time.

Explore more

More short films

More short films end

headlines

On the occasion of Trump's visit to China, the United States blocked the "back door" for Chinese companies to rent AI computing power in Southeast Asia.

China hosts world leaders in an AI wonderland, but what is the other side that they can’t see?

Kaohsiung City Election in Taiwan: "Knowledge Blue" Ke Zhien versus "New Trend" Lai Ruilong. Is it possible for the KMT to copy the "Korean Wave"?

Special recommendation

Popular content