image copyrightGetty Images

Taiwan's "nine-in-one" local elections are entering the countdown, and Beijing's attempts to intervene in Taiwan's election-related activities have attracted renewed attention. In particular, "landed hospitality" tourism, which has become increasingly common in recent years, has been questioned as having a "united front" purpose.

Taiwan’s director of national security stated that a number of related cases have been put under control during this year’s election and are expected to be transferred to judicial authorities for investigation before the election.

However, after the implementation of Taiwan's Anti-Infiltration Law, despite the rapid increase in the number of related cases in recent years, nearly 600 people were investigated and only 5 were convicted, putting the current legal norms and law enforcement standards under scrutiny from the outside world.

The opposition Kuomintang and some critics believe that relevant law enforcement may mislead the public into thinking that all cross-strait exchange activities are restricted, creating a chilling effect.

How does "landing reception" work? Where is the boundary between civil exchanges and united front? Why are these cases difficult to regulate? Judges and scholars analyzed the gray areas and limitations of evidence in Taiwanese law to BBC Chinese.

End of content

image copyrightTaiwan Affairs Office, China

"On-arrival reception": low-cost travel promotes "Two sides of the Taiwan Strait are one family"

Beijing has long claimed that Taiwan is an integral part of its territory and regards "unifying Taiwan" as its core goal. In order to achieve this goal, the CCP mainly implements various united front and infiltration strategies against Taiwan through its "United Front Work Department" (United Front Work Department).

Huang Zhaonian, an associate professor at the National Development Research Institute of Taiwan's National Chengchi University, told BBC Chinese that in the past decade, Beijing's united front strategy against Taiwan has shifted to deepening grassroots society. Since the village chief is located at the lowest level of Taiwan's democratic system and has control over local interpersonal networks and electoral mobilization energy, he is regarded as an important target.

This has caused the village chief’s activities such as visiting China for exchanges and accepting receptions to be scrutinized by the outside world. A high-profile case occurred in September 2023, on the eve of Taiwan’s 2024 presidential election. According to the court ruling, the chief of Qingshan District, Tucheng District, New Taipei City received funding from the Nanjing Taiwan Affairs Office and invited many district chiefs, relatives and friends to travel to China.

End of Hot Reading

The investigation found that participants only had to pay for air tickets, while local food and accommodation were provided by the Chinese side. During the meal talks during the trip, banners saying "Two sides of the Taiwan Strait are one family" were hung on site, and officials from the Taiwan Affairs Office of Nanjing promoted political ideas such as "Blue, White, Harmony" to the attendees.

Taiwan's High Court pointed out in February this year that the mayor accepted funding from infiltration sources and used hospitality and tourism to influence voting intentions in the election, which constituted the crime of anti-infiltration law and voting bribery. He was sentenced to two years and six months in prison.

Another case settled in July this year showed a similar pattern. In August 2023, a Chiayi County councilman accepted instructions from the Taiwan Affairs Office of Taizhou City, Zhejiang Province, China, and invited the Chiayi County village chief and people to participate in a six-day and five-night exchange trip in China. Members only need to pay NT$16,000 (US$486; RMB 3,240), and the rest of the expenses will be subsidized by the Taizhou Taiwan Affairs Office.

The judgment pointed out that relevant personnel used meals and communication activities to promote messages of support for specific candidates to group members. The court found that this move violated the Anti-Infiltration Law and the President and Vice President Election and Recall Law, and sentenced him to guilty.

Questions raised by the low conviction rate of the Anti-Infiltration Law

On the eve of Taiwan's presidential elections in 2016 and 2024, Taiwanese and international media revealed that Beijing used the local Taiwan-related system to subsidize hundreds of Taiwanese village chiefs to visit China. They questioned that such activities have the purpose of "united front" and may even affect Taiwan's elections.

In Taiwan, such cases usually involve violations of the Anti-Infiltration Law, the President and Vice President Election and Recall Law, or the Public Officials Election and Recall Law. Among them, the Anti-Osmosis Law enacted in 2019 plays an important role.

The behaviors punished by the Anti-Infiltration Law include illegal political donations, interference in election activities, illegal lobbying, and the spread of false information to influence the election. In 2025, Taiwan President Lai Ching-te defined China as a "foreign hostile force" covered by the Anti-Infiltration Law, and proposed 17 response strategies in response to China's five major national security and united front threats to Taiwan's national sovereignty, military infiltration, and espionage.

It is worth noting that after the implementation of Taiwan’s Anti-Infiltration Law, the number of related cases increased rapidly, but the number of people who ultimately entered the prosecution or conviction process was relatively limited.

According to statistics released by Taiwan’s Ministry of Justice this year, since the Anti-Infiltration Law was implemented, prosecutors and investigation agencies have investigated 583 people and prosecuted 127 people. Currently, only 5 people have been found guilty by court judgments. The proportion of those who were found guilty accounted for approximately 0.86% of the total number of investigators, and the proportion of those who were determined to be guilty accounted for approximately 3.94% of the number of prosecutors.

Xiaogang, the head of Keelung City, was prosecuted under the Anti-infiltration Law and the President and Vice President Election and Recall Law for taking a group to travel to China. In May this year, he was detained for 23 days and was found not guilty. He has told Taiwanese media many times that the relevant trips have nothing to do with politics or elections and are "pure tourism." Due to the mental pain and impact on his reputation, he sought criminal compensation from the Taiwan government.

This gap has also triggered discussions on the boundaries of law enforcement. Some people question the phenomenon of "more investigations and fewer convictions" in the Anti-Infiltration Law. They believe that even if the parties concerned are not ultimately found to have violated the law, the relevant investigation and case exposure process may still have an impact on personal reputations and even have a chilling effect on cross-strait non-governmental exchanges.

Yang Xinkun, the head of Bianzhou District in Taoyuan City, told BBC Chinese that the Constitution guarantees people's freedom of residence and movement, but some of the regulations proposed by the government in recent years for cross-strait exchanges still need to be clarified in practice, causing grassroots to have concerns when participating in exchange activities.

Judge Xu Kaijie of the National Security and Military Division of the Taipei District Court told BBC Chinese that the relevant figures reflect that law enforcement agencies have indeed found a large number of cases with suspicious signs, but many cases were ultimately not prosecuted due to insufficient evidence, and some were acquitted even if they entered the trial process.

He explained that the constituent elements of the Anti-Infiltration Law are very similar to those of general vote-buying cases. The biggest difference lies in whether the crime involves "accepting instructions, entrustment or funding from foreign hostile forces." If it can be proven that the relevant funds, resources or action instructions come from China or other foreign forces, it may constitute a type of crime regulated by the Anti-Infiltration Law.

"Law enforcement officials are actually quite cautious when applying the Anti-Infiltration Law." He said that from another perspective, this also shows that some of the gray area behaviors that legislators originally hoped to regulate may not be effectively covered by existing laws. It also reflects that judicial agencies face evidence and practical limitations when investigating such cases.

"It is more difficult to investigate than ordinary cases that violate election and strike laws."

image copyrightLok Lee/BBC News Chinese

Why is it difficult to prove?

Xu Kaijie explained that the instructions, funding and entrustment of such cases often occur overseas, making judicial investigation difficult. Since relevant actions often involve China’s official or semi-official system, it is also difficult for Taiwan to obtain evidence through mutual legal assistance.

In addition, tracing related financial flows is also challenging. He pointed out that funds may change hands multiple times, making it more difficult to trace the source; if payments are delivered overseas, or if supervision is circumvented through virtual currencies, etc., the threshold for evidence collection will be further raised.

Xu Kaijie said that there have been some conviction cases in the past that showed that during exchanges in China, there were remarks that clearly related to Taiwan's elections. For example, the leader of the tour expressed to the people traveling with him that he would "vote for a certain candidate" or "not to vote for a certain candidate", or publicly supported a specific candidate with the intention of preventing a specific candidate from being elected. Such behavior may touch the red line of the Law on the Election and Recall of Public Officials.

However, he also pointed out that what is more controversial in practice are those cases where candidates or parties are not mentioned directly. For example, if a political stance is only expressed in a vague way such as "supporting a peaceful political party" during an event, whether it constitutes an illegal act often needs to be determined based on more evidence and the overall situation.

As more and more cases are exposed, the relevant operating methods are also considered to be increasingly obscure. Some law enforcement officials pointed out that some activities no longer directly use words related to Taiwan’s elections, but participants in the activities often understand the political messages and demands they convey.

Yang Xinkun, a village chief who once went to China, believes that this kind of grassroots exchanges mainly belong to interactions at the level of culture and community affairs, and the content mostly focuses on sharing local governance and development experience. The village chief’s exchanges with China “have no political overtones” and “do not need to take it too political.”

image copyrightMinistry of Justice, Taiwan

Restart the debate before the election

With the local elections approaching at the end of November, Taiwan's National Security Director Tsai Ming-yan said last week that he has currently managed about 100 cases involving China's interference in the election, and hopes to transfer them to judicial authorities for investigation before the election.

In August this year, prosecutors’ offices across Taiwan successively sent letters to the district chiefs within their jurisdictions. In addition to promoting anti-vote buying, anti-ticket selling, and prevention of ghost populations, they also reminded people to pay attention to the provisions of the Anti-Infiltration Law, including preventing foreign interference in elections, and the possible legal liabilities involved in accepting subsidies or traveling to China for free or at low prices.

This move triggered controversy in public opinion. The opposition Kuomintang party questioned that the judicial authorities included cross-strait exchanges and exchange activities in China in the name of promoting the rule of law, which may be "false propaganda and actual intimidation."

Some critics also believe that the relevant information may mislead the public into thinking that all cross-strait exchange activities are restricted, and even interpret it as pressure on grassroots officials.

In response, Zhang Han, spokesperson for the Taiwan Affairs Office of China, responded that every time there is an election in Taiwan, the Democratic Progressive Party will deliberately manipulate "resisting China and safeguarding Taiwan" and hyping up the so-called "Mainland-introduced election" issue in order to seek political gain. She also pointed out that the Democratic Progressive Party government uses prosecutorial and judicial means to threaten the people, describing this move as "green terror."

Taiwan's Supreme Prosecutor's Office responded that the contents listed in the relevant letters have legal basis and are intended to educate the public on the rule of law and promote election laws, and are not intended to restrict legitimate cross-strait exchange activities.

risk management

Whether it is a united front or an exchange, there are different interpretations in the eyes of Taiwan's grassroots. Experts also emphasized that not all exchanges with China involve political manipulation, but the key point is that the current legal system lacks transparency and reporting mechanisms.

According to Taiwan's "Cross-Strait People's Relations Regulations", civil servants traveling to China must fulfill relevant notification obligations. However, the district chief is not applicable to the Civil Service Law, and no prior application or notification is required to travel to China. Due to the lack of a complete disclosure mechanism, when a village director travels to China as an individual or as an exchange group, the content of the itinerary, contacts and funding sources are often less likely to be inspected by the outside world.

Xu Kaijie believes that Taiwan still has room for improvement in institutional design. One direction is to improve information transparency. For example, refer to the Foreign Agent Registration System established in some countries in recent years, which requires participants in specific political activities or related organizations to disclose the source of funds and whether they accept funding from foreign governments or overseas hostile forces.

He said that if there are difficulties in collecting criminal evidence, the government can first strengthen the disclosure obligation through administrative control mechanisms instead of immediately using criminal penalties as the main method. Declaration and registration may be required in the early stages of the system. If you deliberately conceal or fail to declare in accordance with the law, you will be held accountable in accordance with the law.

"Of course, some people simply want to see the scenery of mainland China or understand the local development, and that is understandable." Xu Kaijie said that normal cross-strait people-to-people exchanges should not and cannot be prohibited, but for behaviors involving infiltration for foreign forces, the government should still conduct necessary supervision and management of related risks.

Explore more

More short films

More short films end

Five highlights of Taiwan's "nine-in-one" election: Can "ocean currents" shake Taipei? Who's in the running for the 2028 election?

Taiwan's New Taipei mayoral election: "Second-generation politician" Su Qiaohui versus "professional deputy" Li Sichuan, who can win the key blue-green city?

Taiwan's local elections: 40% of "mainland-affiliated" candidates were excluded from the election. How does the "legal and legal knot" of identity hinder the path to political participation?

2026 Taiwan local elections: Why is "nine-in-one" important? What is the election schedule?

Interpretation of Taiwan’s elections: Is the political landscape of “Blue in the North and Green in the South” “monolithic”?

After Tsai Kangyong said he "never supported Taiwan independence", he attended Chiang Wanan's rally. Public opinion on both sides of the Taiwan Strait still remains.

headlines

APEC Shenzhen Summit Preview: China confirms the meeting between the United States, China and Russia, and Japan hopes that Xi Jinping will shake hands with the high market as usual

Jen-Hsun Huang reportedly discussed returning to Nvidia, Megaspeed said Huang Le left last year

What will the historic meeting between Xi Jinping, Trump and Putin mean to the world?

Special recommendation

Popular content