Image source: Getty Images

Films flopping at the box office, audiences rejecting formulaic films, not being able to connect with remakes of South Indian films and interference by star managers in the script writing of films, all these are some of the reasons which are said to be creating obstacles in the way of the audience coming to the theatres.

In the third and final part of this episode, we will know why many Hindi films are not successful, what kind of films the audience wants to watch after the Corona epidemic and what can be done to bring them back to the theaters.

We spoke to trade analyst Taran Adarsh, producer Firoz A Nadiadwala, filmmaker Ahmed Khan and marketing expert Varun Gupta about this.

Apart from this, we also took opinion in this regard from Nitin Gupta and Gaurav Mishra associated with the multiplex industry.

End

Audience's preferences changed after Corona: Taran Adarsh

Trade analyst Taran Adarsh ​​said that Bollywood's film model is extremely risky, because every Friday our success or failure completely depends on the audience's choice.

He said, "Many times even the films of the biggest stars do not do well, while on the other hand suddenly a new artiste gets success. In today's era, no one can say with certainty how a film will perform at the box office or which film will live up to the expectations of the audience."

He says, "The Corona pandemic is also a major reason for increasing uncertainty in the business of Hindi cinema. During that time, people had limited means of entertainment, so they started watching more TV, OTT platforms and Hindi dubbed versions of South Indian films. The kind of content people watched during the pandemic changed their preferences and thinking. They got to see different, more modern and outspoken stories than before."

"At the same time, people who were watching Hindi dubbed versions of South Indian films felt that Bollywood's masala films were no longer fun. On the other hand, films aimed at urban audiences and based on social issues increased in multiplexes. In such an environment, masala films started being ridiculed. The result was that Bollywood kept moving away from its large audience."

Taran explains, "After the pandemic, the audience has started choosing films more thoughtfully than before. This is why today many films do not take a good start at the box office, whereas films like Pushpa, Jawan and Animal get tremendous openings. These films have proved the power of cinema, which can reach out to the urban, educated and middle class audiences as well as the general public."

Taran Adarsh ​​said that this is the reason why masala films have made a comeback after the pandemic, because these films attract a large section of the audience.

"It is important to connect the audience living outside the metros with the mainstream of cinema, in this, single screen theaters also play an important role. Only in some selected metros, the audience likes to watch films based on the urban environment. This is a mirror for those filmmakers who want to make a particular kind of film and consider masala cinema to be cheap or substandard."

Image source: Jio Studios

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

Taran Adarsh ​​said, "The truth is that the survival of the film industry is completely dependent on mass cinema. The kind of business that films like Welcome to the Jungle, Dhamaal 4, Awarapan 2, Dhurandhar, Dhurandhar 2, Bhoot Bangla and Hanuman Ansh have done outside the metros is fantastic."

"Another reason for Hindi cinema not doing well is the manager culture that has developed around the stars. These people neither have any connection with the film industry nor do they understand its pulse. They ignore the experienced filmmakers who have years of experience. At the same time, the star managers consider these filmmakers to be of the past. But the truth is that films are not made in the boardroom, but with love, passion and dedication."

He says, "Music has always played a big role in attracting the audience. Earlier, the songs of films were released much before their release. These songs used to act like brand ambassadors of that film and used to draw the audience to the theatres. But in today's era, we do not give that much time to music and writing."

"Many times the story of a film is one thing when it is narrated and by the time it comes on screen, it changes so much that the two appear to be completely different films. Artists should stop interfering in script writing and other departments of film production."

Strong content is necessary for the success of a film: Firoz Nadiadwala

Producer Firoz A. Nadiadwala says that the success of a film in Bollywood largely depends on its story, theme and selection of the right actors. If the story is good and the right actors are chosen accordingly, then the risk of the film being a flop is reduced to a great extent.

Nadiadwala made Welcome 4 this year, which did a worldwide business of around Rs 200 crore.

According to him, "When the story is right and the actors are selected accordingly, then the possibility of risk is reduced to a great extent. There is a difference between a big budget film and a big budget film with extravagant expenditure. There is also a big budget film in which every single penny is spent thoughtfully and the effect of which is clearly visible on the screen. The risk of such a film is reduced to a great extent."

He said that the risk increases when the re-shooting of the film continues continuously or the budget goes beyond the stipulated limit.

He said, "Our effort should be to make a good film that can be watched with the family and its budget should also be kept under control. Before making a film, it is also important to keep in mind how much earning is expected before its release. The film should be completed within the stipulated time and there should be no compromise on its quality during this time. Also, the budget should not increase. Apart from the box office after the release of the film, the earnings from digital, satellite and music rights should also be kept in mind."

"If your product is going to entertain people, then you have to understand the pulse of the audience. You can entertain someone by scaring them, making them cry, laughing or thrilling them. With this in mind, we have coined the term 'Family Universe' for our company. That is, such entertainment, which the whole family can watch together and no one feels uncomfortable."

"Star power alone is not enough to bring a film to the theatres. The star's popularity may definitely get you a certain number of viewers, but if the film does not have strong content, what will you show the audience? If the content is strong, star power can increase its impact manifold."

"Content, dialogues, screenplay and characters, all are equally important to make a great film franchise. Our franchises like Welcome, Hera Pheri and Awara Pagal Deewana are examples of this."

Director-producer Ahmed Khan, who made the multi-starrer film 'Baap' with stars like Sunny Deol, Sanjay Dutt, Jackie Shroff and Mithun Chakraborty, says, "The risk is huge for film makers. If the film does not perform well, the producer's image also gets affected. According to me, the model of earning and recouping the cost of a film is divided into five phases - box office, digital, satellite, music and overseas i.e. foreign market."

Ahmed Khan said, "Film making is a democratic process, in which everyone from the director and producer to the actors, technicians and studios have a role to play."

"Today, the number of audiences going to theaters is limited, but they want a reason for which they go to watch a film. Be it a love story with a new cast or a war-based drama. If the film is interesting, the audience will definitely go to watch it."

"Every filmmaker is trying to attract the audience, but the first stage of the film i.e. trailer and teaser only decides how much curiosity will be created in the minds of the audience to watch the film. We should release the right trailer after understanding the preferences of the audience."

"Before the pandemic, the film industry had never seen a business level of Rs 1,000 crore. This means that people are going to theaters in large numbers. So I do not believe that the number of viewers has decreased. In fact, now even the viewers watching movies on OTT are returning to theaters."

"The basic strategy of making a film is neither big budget nor big stars. For me, making a film like Welcome to the Jungle is event cinema, in which so many actors are in one frame and in every scene they are seen doing such ridiculous acts which the audience loves to watch."

"A love story with a new couple can also be an event cinema, if the audience gets a glimpse of their youth and old memories in it. The third type of event film is the one which has great action, car chases, explosions, horses, many heroes and their powerful dialogues. Event cinema has always worked."

Audience is now giving more importance to content than stardom: Varun Gupta

Image source: Nasir Kachroo/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Varun Gupta, Founder-Director of Max Marketing, says that the decision to make a film in Bollywood is largely taken keeping in mind its business prospects. Before starting work on a film, its story, genre, previous record of the director and the performance of the actors in previous films are assessed.

According to him, the preferences of the educated class, upper middle class and Gen Z audience have changed a lot in the last decade. These audiences now give more importance to the content of the film than stardom. Varun Gupta considers this a good thing for those filmmakers who want to make films on different and interesting subjects.

He said, "Today's audience is intelligent, aware and familiar with cinema from around the world. They easily understand what is mere show on screen and what is real and authentic content that connects with them."

According to Varun Gupta, earlier the audience used to go to theaters after seeing big stars in a film, but now the situation has changed. To bring the audience back to the theaters, the right combination of content, star power and grandeur according to the level of the film is necessary.

Giving an example of this, he said that in 'Ramayana' a combination of big stars from different film industries, stories related to Indian culture and grandeur can be seen.

Varun Gupta believes that it has become difficult for films like crime thrillers to bring audiences to theaters, because OTT is being considered more suitable for such films. However, citing examples of films like 'Laapta Ladies', 'Munjya', '12th Fail' and 'Hanuman Ansh', he said that good films can still draw the audience to theatres.

He said, "During the pandemic, the audience has become more savvy than before by watching content from around the world on OTT while sitting at home. As long as there is strong belief in storytelling and the right planning of the producer, the audience will keep flocking to theatres."

He also said that the audience should feel that their money and time have been utilized well. Cinema owners and film distributors also have an important role in this. From ticket prices to the experience at the cinema, many factors influence a viewer's decision.

According to Varun Gupta, it is important to maintain a balance between creativity and business in film production. Directors should work on the basis of their creative thinking and intuition, while producers should keep in mind the business strategy along with it.

He said, "Producer and director should not mix their respective work i.e. creative freedom and commercial feasibility. It is only when this happens that the project starts deviating from its path."

What is needed to bring audiences to theatres?

Image source, ANI/X@HanumanAnsh

Nitin Gupta, Head of Operations, NXT Cinema, says that as an audience, to watch a Hindi film, they should be attracted by its theme, director, cast and trailer.

According to him, "The preferences of audiences in every city and different social classes may be different, but content is most important for every class."

Citing the example of the success of Gujarati film 'Lalo' and Hindi film 'Hanuman Ansh', he said that these films have done excellent business and have gained popularity among all sections of the audience.

Nitin Gupta believes that good content is most important to bring the audience back to the theaters. According to him, with the presence of big stars, a film can get a good start on the weekend, but if its story and content is not strong, then it cannot survive at the box office for long.

Meanwhile, Gaurav Mishra, an executive at a multiplex chain, says that today's audience, irrespective of age or social class, wants to watch stories that entertain them, keep them engaged and leave an impression on them.

He told that the working class wants such entertainment in which one gets full value for the money spent. The middle class audience wants a completely entertaining cinematic experience with the family. While educated audiences prefer strong storytelling and originality, Gen Z looks for freshness, relatability and an immersive cinematic experience.

According to Gaurav Mishra, "Ultimately every viewer wants to watch a film that is worth his time."

He said that to bring the audience back to the theatres, it is important to continuously provide good quality films, cinema of different genres, affordable ticket rates and better theater experience.

Gaurav Mishra believes that the future of theater cinema in India is very bright. He said, "As long as such stories continue to be made, which make the experience of watching them on the big screen special and the audience is ready to celebrate them together, the magic of the big screen will continue."

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

Bangladesh: Violence in Gopalganj demanding return of Sheikh Hasina, government removed DC and SP

Live, Jay Shah again becomes ICC Chairman, elected unopposed

Why are Hindi films failing at the box office, how can audiences be brought back to theatres?

must read

most popular