image copyrightEPA
U.S. President Donald Trump attended the trilateral summit with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping without a clear agenda or specific demands. And even when returning from the meeting, it appears that there were very few results achieved.
In the end, what will be remembered for a long time from this summit may not be the actual results of the meeting, but its external appearance, the so-called 'show scene' as it is commonly called in the political world.
Some evaluated this meeting as a historic 'Yalta 2.0' meeting where leaders of powerful countries gathered in one place.
In the end, what President Trump wanted most from this meeting may have been extravagant protocols and events.
President Trump, who suffered a political blow with the Republican Party's crushing defeat in the midterm elections earlier this month, enjoyed having the world's attention focused on him throughout his three-day trip to Asia. In particular, satisfaction was expressed in highlighting the historical significance of the first trilateral summit between the United States, Russia, and China.
In an interview with Fox News on the 18th, President Trump evaluated the trip as already a success, citing the fact that he sat in the spotlight at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) dinner held on the 17th and the welcome he received upon his arrival in China.
He cited the 'fanfare and beauty, splendid protocol, and thousands of welcoming crowds' at the time as the basis for this.
The standards may seem too low. But for the U.S. president, that alone may have been a satisfying enough achievement.
End of TOP News
However, after the three-nation summit ended, the U.S. side has remained unusually silent to this day.
China quickly released a joint statement detailing the content of the meeting, and Russian President Vladimir Putin also held a press conference for about an hour immediately after the meeting to explain the details of the discussion.
On the other hand, President Trump did not make any public remarks and merely announced that he would hold a press conference at the White House on the 20th.
When President Trump visited China early this year or after meeting with President Xi Jinping at the APEC summit held in Korea in October last year, he met with the media early on his private plane returning to Washington.
Currently, the White House has incorporated its position in a joint statement issued after the three-nation summit on the 19th. However, most of the statement's content is in principle that it supports efforts to ensure 'strategic stability and international security.'
This joint statement, showing the leaders of the three major powers gathered in one place to discuss world issues in a friendly manner, can at least provide a sense of relief that there is no possibility of a catastrophic conflict breaking out any time soon.
However, other than a promise to continue further 'dialogue' and a reaffirmation of the principle that nuclear war 'should never occur', there is little substantive content beyond rhetoric.
David Firestein, director of the Bush Foundation's Center for US-China Relations, told the BBC: "Overall, it is good to have the leaders of the world's major powers coming together in a variety of formats, even if the results appear to be minimal at best."
The statement to 'expand production and supply' of refined petroleum products contained in the joint statement appears to be aimed at Russia, a major supplier to the international fossil fuel market.
Content condemning the International Criminal Court (ICC), which has recently been the subject of criticism by the United States, is also notable.
If the leaders of the world's three major powers can agree on at least one issue, it would be that multilateral international organizations that seek to enforce international law should not be given substantive authority to support such efforts.
During his visit to China, President Trump called President Putin his "friend" and boasted of his "excellent personal relationship" with President Xi Jinping after shaking hands and hugging him.
But things could change when President Trump returns to Washington.
The views of U.S. political circles regarding his trip to Asia are likely to range from cautious concern to outright criticism.
Republican Senator John Curtis (Utah) said in a statement to the BBC on the 19th, "I am concerned about how we are defining our relationships with our geopolitical adversaries. Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping are not our friends."
He continued, “Diplomacy is important, but it should not be done at the expense of a clear understanding of who our adversaries are.”
Republican Representative Darrin LaHood (Illinois), who was re-elected with President Trump's support earlier this month, said that the United States must dialogue with its allies and adversaries abroad. However, he defined President Putin as a 'dictator' and an 'international criminal'.
“It is somewhat concerning that a scene has been created that appears to give Putin equal status with the United States on the world stage,” LaHood told BBC News.
“We must remember what Putin did in Ukraine,” he said. “He invaded a sovereign, independent democratic country, and he continues to commit aggression there.”
The Democratic Party offered a more direct criticism.
“America’s security should not be traded for photo opportunities or personal prestige,” nine Democratic lawmakers on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee wrote in a letter to the White House.
President Trump is not the first U.S. president to seek a breakthrough on the international diplomatic stage to make up for domestic political damage. Former Democratic Presidents Bill Clinton and Barack Obama also went on overseas trips immediately after their respective parties lost in the midterm elections.
However, the increase in political approval ratings that both former presidents achieved through their trips did not last long.
President Trump may have created the scenes he wanted at this Asian summit, but since there were no tangible results to back it up, there is a high possibility that this trip will soon be forgotten in people's memories.
*Additional reporting: Brandon Drennan




