Image source: Hannah Peters/Getty Images

India has won the five-match ODI series against New Zealand 3-1. But despite this victory, questions are being raised on the team's batting.

Indian team's head coach Gautam Gambhir had expressed concern over the performance of the batsmen after the crushing defeat in the fourth ODI against New Zealand. Now former Indian captain and former head coach Ravi Shastri has also justified Gambhir's concerns.

In the fourth ODI played at Mount Maunganui on 13 November, the Indian team was all out for just 89 runs. New Zealand won this match by 244 runs. Two days later, India won the fifth ODI by 22 runs and clinched the series, but in this match also the Indian batsmen could score only 209 runs.

ये प्रदर्शन इसलिए भी अहम है क्योंकि 2027 में वनडे विश्व कप खेला जाना है. टूर्नामेंट की मेज़बानी दक्षिण अफ़्रीका, ज़िम्बाब्वे और नामीबिया करेंगे. गंभीर का मानना है कि न्यूज़ीलैंड में बल्लेबाज़ों को जिन परिस्थितियों का सामना करना पड़ा, वे विश्व कप में मिलने वाली चुनौतियों से काफ़ी मिलती-जुलती हो सकती हैं.

How did the Indian team get reduced to 89 runs?

Image source: Michael Bradley / AFP via Getty Images

On 13 November, at the Bay Oval, New Zealand batted first and scored 333 runs in 50 overs.

For New Zealand, Will Young played an inning of 125 runs in 108 balls. Tim Seifert scored 58 and Finn Allen scored 41 runs.

The Indian team, which set out to chase the target of 334 runs, had a very bad start.

New Zealand fast bowler Matt Henry sent Rohit Sharma, Virat Kohli and Shreyas Iyer to the pavilion without opening the account in the very first over. Indian team's score became zero runs for three wickets.

End

After this, Rituraj Gaikwad also got out after scoring five runs and India lost four wickets for just nine runs.

Ishan Kishan tried to control the innings by scoring 27 runs and Akshar Patel scored 21 runs, but the Indian team was all out for 89 runs in 26.4 overs.

Matt Henry took six wickets for 27 runs. This was India's second biggest defeat by margin of runs in ODI cricket.

What did Gautam Gambhir say about the batsmen?

Image source: Ayush Kumar/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images

After the defeat in the fourth ODI, Gautam Gambhir spoke openly about the performance of the Indian batsmen in the press conference.

Gambhir said that when a team is all out for around 90 runs, it is natural to be worried.

According to him, the biggest problem was not just scoring less runs, but the speed with which the Indian team lost its wickets was a matter of greater concern.

Gambhir said that India will have to prepare better at both mental and technical levels in conditions like New Zealand.

He also emphasized the importance of the first 10 overs. According to Gambhir, the first 10 to 15 overs are often easy to bat on Indian pitches, but in New Zealand this time can be the most difficult.

Gambhir also said that in international cricket, no ball should be considered difficult to such an extent that the batsmen cannot face it. According to him, Matt Henry bowled on a good line and length, but the Indian batsmen should have been able to face him.

Why did Gambhir even mention the second ODI?

Gautam Gambhir's worry was not just about being all out for 89 runs in the fourth ODI.

He also gave the example of the second ODI of the series.

India had to chase the target of 135 runs in the rain-affected match played in Wellington on November 7.

India won this match by four runs under the Duckworth-Lewis-Stern i.e. DLS rule.

Gambhir said that the weakness of batting is not being discussed just because of losing one match. Even in the earlier won match, the fall of seven wickets was a matter of concern.

It was clear from his statement that the Indian team will have to find a solution to the problem of continuous fall of wickets in difficult conditions.

Why did Ravi Shastri support Gambhir's concern?

Image source: Ranjith Kumar/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

After India's victory in the fifth ODI against New Zealand, former cricketer and team coach Ravi Shastri also agreed with Gautam Gambhir's concern regarding batting.

Shastri said on Sony Sports, "Gambhir was right that the conditions in New Zealand are important for the next World Cup to be held in South Africa."

Shastri said that better performance will be expected from Indian batsmen in future. According to him, the batsmen will have to show patience in difficult situations and learn to overcome such periods of the game when the bowlers dominate.

He said that one cannot enter every match with the target of scoring 300 or 320 runs.

According to Shastri, on some pitches even 260 or 270 runs can be enough to win the match.

His comment meant that in ODI cricket, batsmen will have to change their strategy according to the circumstances.

Where the fast bowlers are getting help on the pitch, it may be more important to save wickets and build long partnerships rather than scoring runs quickly.

What do Indian batting statistics tell?

Image source: Joe Allison/Getty Images

The batting performance of the Indian team on the New Zealand tour is also visible in the statistics.

In the entire ODI series, no Indian batsman could reach the total of 100 runs.

In the series, the batsmen of both the teams had to face difficulties in front of the initial swing and seam movement of the ball.

Another concern for India is the difference in batting performance in home and away conditions.

In the matches played after Champions Trophy 2025, India's middle order (batsmen from fourth to seventh position) scored runs at an average of 47.75 and strike rate of 110.72 in 12 matches on home grounds.

In contrast, on foreign grounds, middle order batsmen scored runs at an average of only 24.64 in 11 matches and their strike rate was 79.58.

These figures show a huge difference in the performance of India's middle order in domestic and overseas conditions.

Why did Shreyas Iyer say that we cannot compare South Africa and New Zealand?

Image source: Sanka VIDANAGAMA / AFP via Getty Images

While Gautam Gambhir and Ravi Shastri are linking the batting difficulties in New Zealand to the preparations for the 2027 World Cup, Indian captain Shreyas Iyer has taken a slightly different view.

After winning the series, Iyer said that the conditions of New Zealand and South Africa cannot be compared directly.

According to him, the weather and playing conditions may be different in both the places.

Iyer also admitted that the bowlers got help in New Zealand and it was difficult for the batsmen of both the teams to score runs.

However, he stressed that the most important goal of the team was to win the series and India managed to achieve it.

According to Iyer, this tour will give every player an opportunity to learn and it is important to make changes in the game according to different conditions.

Which big titles did India win after Gautam Gambhir became the coach?

Gautam Gambhir was appointed the head coach of the Indian men's cricket team on July 9, 2024.

He had replaced Rahul Dravid, during whose tenure India won the 2024 T20 World Cup.

During Gambhir's tenure, the Indian team has won three major tournaments so far. These include the 2025 Champions Trophy, 2025 Asia Cup and 2026 T20 World Cup.

What are the challenges facing India before the 2027 World Cup?

Image source: Johan Rynners-ICC/ICC via Getty Images

Despite winning the ODI series against New Zealand, India has many questions.

The biggest question is about the performance of the batsmen in foreign conditions. The manner in which the Indian batsmen were out quickly in front of the fast bowlers in New Zealand has intensified the discussion on the preparations for the 2027 World Cup.

The second question is about the balance and options of the batting order. Due to Shubman Gill and KL Rahul not playing in the last two ODIs against New Zealand, changes had to be made in the top order of the team.

The third challenge is that of fielding. Dropped catches and other mistakes in the series showed that India needed to improve in this area as well.

However, the New Zealand tour has also given positive signals for Indian bowling. The performance of Arshdeep Singh, Gurnoor Brar and other fast bowlers showed that the team has the ability to turn the match in its favor in difficult situations.

The comments of Gautam Gambhir and Ravi Shastri indicate that just scoring big will not be enough to be successful in the 2027 World Cup. The team will also have to work on saving wickets on difficult pitches, batting according to the conditions and taking advantage of opportunities in fielding.

India has returned after winning the ODI series from New Zealand, but how strong are its preparations to win the next World Cup will be answered only by the performance of the batsmen in the upcoming matches.

What do the pitches of South Africa and New Zealand have in common?

Image source, Christiaan Kotze / AFP via Getty Images

One reason for Gautam Gambhir's concern about the performance of Indian batsmen in New Zealand is the 2027 ODI World Cup. This tournament is to be played in South Africa, Zimbabwe and Namibia.

Indian captain Shubman Gill had said before the New Zealand tour that the conditions there are more similar to South Africa than the other countries where India has to play.

According to Gill, the weather in New Zealand at this time of year could also be close to the conditions expected during the World Cup in South Africa.

The pace and bounce available on South African pitches has also been mentioned by the head coach of South Africa, Shukri Conrad.

Conrad had said that South African pitches have traditionally been favorable for fast bowlers and have bounce.

However, Conrad also said that spin bowlers have also got some help at the Wanderers ground in Johannesburg in recent times.

According to the official schedule of ICC, 2027 World Cup matches will be played on eight grounds in South Africa.

The Indian team will play its first group match against Australia in Cape Town on October 7, 2027. After this, it will face Pakistan in Johannesburg on October 10.

In such a situation, batting according to different conditions will be an important aspect of the Indian team's preparations.

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

Why is Gautam Gambhir worried even after winning the ODI series in New Zealand, Shastri also expressed concern

Live, Yemen's army retreats from the important sea route of the Red Sea, captured by Houthi rebels

Bilkis Bano gangrape case: Supreme Court suspends sentence of two convicts, grants bail

must read

most popular