Credit, Gilson Ferreira/Government of Maranhão
The tributes to Raimundo Nina Rodrigues in Brazil are multiple. The São Luís do Maranhão psychiatric hospital was named after the coroner from Maranhão; a municipality with 14 thousand residents in the same State; the Legal Medical Institute of Salvador, in Bahia; a noble street in the south of Rio de Janeiro, as well as several other public places spread across the country.
In the Rio neighborhood of Jardim Botânico, the sign on Rua Nina Rodrigues describes the biography of the man from Maranhão who died 120 years ago in small letters: "1862-1906. Doctor, professor of legal medicine, criminalist, sociologist, ethnologist, folklorist."
But it is silent on the ideas of Nina Rodrigues, who was an exponent of scientific racism in Brazil at the turn of the century and defended racial hierarchies – arguing, for example, based on craniological studies, that "inferior races" such as black and indigenous people were prone to crime or violence.
In São Luís, an unprecedented popular action is fighting in court for the State of Maranhão to remove the name of this historical figure from the Nina Rodrigues State Psychiatric Hospital, asking for the annulment of the administrative act that named the hospital in the 1940s, arguing that the tribute would be an act harmful to the constitutional principle of administrative morality.
In January, the action won victory in the first instance, with a ruling determining the nullity of the administrative act that named the hospital and the removal of Nina Rodrigues' name.
The State of Maranhão appealed, and the trial in the second instance is scheduled for December 10th, in a collegiate session in the Second Chamber of Public Law, at the Court of Justice of Maranhão.
'Historical reparation movement'
Credit, Personal file
Author of the action, lawyer Thiago Cruz argues that the state psychiatric hospital – a reference public facility that serves patients from more than 220 municipalities in Maranhão – does not deserve to remain associated with "one of the main exponents of eugenic and racial theses" in Brazil. This is in the state that has the third highest proportion of black and brown people in the country, equivalent to 79% of the population.
"It was an achievement", he tells BBC News Brasil about the decision in the first instance. "São Luís society is very conservative, and we received several rejection notes asking for the action to be dismissed, but it sets an important judicial precedent in the debate on historical and transitional justice", he celebrates.
End of Most read
Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service
Download here
End of app promotion
In Salvador, the name of the Instituto Médico Legal Nina Rodrigues was also recently called into question, although without producing concrete effects to date. In 2022, the Public Defender's Office of Bahia recommended that the state government change the name of the unit as a way to combat "institutional racism." According to the Technical Police Department, to which the IML is subordinate, the request is under analysis by the Attorney General of the State of Bahia.
The initiatives reflect a worldwide movement to question tributes to racist historical figures or those linked to the past of slavery, inspired by examples such as Black Lives Matter, which generated global mobilization during the pandemic.
"It's a historical reparation movement, which seeks to denaturalize heroes or great names of honored people and understand who they actually were", describes historian Ynaê Lopes dos Santos, professor of American History at Universidade Federal Fluminense (UFF). "In the case of Nina Rodrigues, one of the greatest representatives of scientific racism in Brazil, this is fundamental."
Miscegenation and 'degeneration'
Credit, Public Domain
Raimundo Nina Rodrigues was born in 1862 in Vargem Grande (MA). He divided his medical studies between Bahia and Rio de Janeiro, where he graduated in 1888, later settling in Salvador.
He became a reference as a coroner, psychiatrist and academic in the First Republic, a time when these categories were consolidated and became closer to public policies, and Brazil had just abolished slavery. His circle of influence generated a group of doctors called Escola Nina Rodrigues.
His formation was strongly linked to scientific racism, an ideology that, according to Ynaê Lopes dos Santos, prevailed in the West at the time, with great influence from the Italian doctor and criminologist Cesare Lombroso, also a eugenicist.
Rodrigues considered that blacks and indigenous people were biologically inferior, and that miscegenation would lead to "degeneration". He even defended the existence of two separate penal codes, opposing the Penal Code of 1890 (the first in the Republic) because he considered that human races had different predispositions for certain crimes, and, therefore, imputability should also be different.
"As in his view black people were born with a biological condition that led them to commit certain crimes, he argued that their punishment could not be the same as that of white people. It should be less, because they would be in line with their nature", describes the historian.
"And if black people were more prone to robberies, then the police would always look more carefully at them. This was something that was very publicized, and unfortunately we live with the remnants of this to this day."
Credit, National Archives
In society in São Luís, the legal action requesting the withdrawal of the tribute to the Maranhão native generated protests among intellectual associations. Notes of repudiation came from the Instituto Histórico e Geográfico do Maranhão (IHGM), the Academia Maranhense de Letras and the Associação Maranhense de Psiquiatria, highlighting the importance of Nina Rodrigues' contributions and her pioneering spirit in several areas of study, from criminal anthropology to legal medicine and Afro-Brazilian studies.
IHGM participated in the popular action as a friend of the court (amicus curiae), opposing the change of name of the hospital alongside the defendant, the State of Maranhão. In a manifesto letter, he called on intellectuals from Maranhão to "close ranks for the preservation of Maranhão and national memory" and defend the maintenance of the tribute to Nina Rodrigues.
Opponents accuse the action of "historical revisionism", and argue that Rodrigues' actions be seen in the light of the ideas in force at the time.
End of content
'Unprecedented' process
Judge Douglas de Melo Martins, who judged the case at first instance, considers this view to be a "very low" criticism.
"Much of our racism, which survives strongly today, comes from our inability to reevaluate a completely wrong view of the world that prevailed in the past", says Martins, who is a judge at the Diffuse and Collective Interests Court of São Luís.
"This vision has not ceased to exist. And when public authorities maintain tributes of this nature, they are promoting, strengthening, reproducing this same vision, which is projected over time thanks to this tribute", he argues.
In an interview with BBC News Brasil, he highlights that the action is unprecedented.
"It is the first case in which a judicial process discusses the possible removal of a tribute by a public entity to a historical figure that has some association with racism."
In the sentence, the judge emphasizes that changing the hospital's name would not represent an "individual attack on the doctor", but rather the State's duty "to disassociate itself from a racist ideological project". He refers to the Federal Constitution and international treaties signed by Brazil to combat racism, defending affirmative measures to implement transitional justice and face "the still present repercussions of slavery, racism and eugenics in Brazilian society".
Martins hopes that the sentence shows that the Judiciary is prepared to act when the Executive fails. He predicts that the case could reach the STF, which would be an "opportunity" for the court to reach an understanding on the matter.
Despite accepting the name change, the ruling denied the second request made in the popular action: that the hospital be renamed in honor of Juliano Moreira, considered one of the founders of psychiatry in Brazil.
The judge understood that the choice of the new name would be the responsibility of the Executive Branch, but recommended that the request in favor of Moreira be considered, highlighting the importance of the doctor from Bahia, who was black, in humanizing the treatment of mental illnesses and combating scientific racism.
State's challenge
In the appeal, the State of Maranhão maintains, through the Attorney General's Office of the State of Maranhão (PGE-MA), that the administrative act that named the hospital in the 1940s has long since passed the 5-year statute of limitations provided for by the Popular Action Law.
Argues that the popular action route is inadequate to generate an "obligation to do" for the State (referring to the request to change the name of the hospital and rename it Juliano Moreira); and that the author had not demonstrated "injury to administrative morality". Finally, he states that the action violates the separation of powers by interfering with an Executive function, describing it as "a classic case of judicial activism."
Consulted by BBC News Brasil, PGE-MA stated in a note that, if the sentence is confirmed and after final judgment, "the judicial decision will be duly complied with by the State".
The Prosecutor's Office also stated that "it does not condone any discriminatory practices, and it is essential to distinguish this institutional position from the technical-procedural theses formulated in the State's judicial defense in a specific case, especially when they have a central focus on formal issues of the process."
Credit, Júlia Dias Carneiro/BBC
'Bad joke'
Lawyer responsible for the action, Thiago Cruz is 33 years old. He was born in Codó, in the interior of Maranhão, and moved to São Luís as a child. He had the idea of proposing the action after watching Holocausto Brasileiro, a documentary based on the book of the same name by Daniela Arbex about the atrocities committed at the Centro Hospitalar Psiquiátrico de Barbacena, known as Hospital Colônia, in Minas Gerais, in the 1960s-80s.
The discomfort with the series led Cruz to reflect on the psychiatric hospital in his own city.
“It’s such a bad joke that you have the name of a racist figure in a psychiatric institution,” he says.
Cruz decided to sue the State of Maranhão with a popular action, a judicial instrument provided for by the Constitution that allows any citizen to go to court to annul acts harmful to collective assets, as long as they are up to date with their political rights. Presented in April 2024, the action gave it a new projection.
"Here in São Luís, I'm basically an underdog. Nobody knew me, I'm not anyone's political sponsor. When there was the first public hearing, a lot of people asked where I came from", says the lawyer, who is active in land struggle initiatives and works in collectives in defense of social movements, informal workers, indigenous and quilombola communities.
The lawyer hopes that the case will reverberate nationally and pave the way for "the removal of the names of racist figures, generals and people who do not support the democratic ideal" from buildings and public places.
He highlights the importance of the technical note that the Federal Public Defender's Office (DPU) prepared in January 2025 based on the action, making recommendations for cases across the country.
In the opinion, the DPU considered the removal of the name of "people associated with slavery, racism and eugenics" from public places an "adequate, reasonable, current and fair" measure in favor of historical reparation, with the capacity to "produce a reverse effect to the tribute paid in the past" and show that the Brazilian State "does not condone the maintenance of deferences fraught with violence against vulnerable groups, especially against the Brazilian black population."
'Things are changing'
At "Nina", as the Nina Rodrigues Hospital is called by those who attend or work there, a long-time employee says he is following the fight to change the institution's name with interest – but claims to be in the minority.
"People here are very out of touch. There are people who say 'ah, but why are you going to change your name?', without even knowing who Nina Rodrigues was", says the employee, who prefers not to identify himself.
"I research, I know that Nina Rodrigues said that black people were predisposed to crime. It makes no sense for an institution that carried out psychiatric reform to humanize care to have the name of a guy who preached scientific racism", he considers. "A lot of people say he left a lot of contributions, but be patient. Things have changed. Things are changing."
In Rio de Janeiro, Rua Nina Rodrigues occupies a bucolic block between Rua Jardim Botânico and a hillside that leads into the Tijuca Forest.
Doorman José Rogério da Silva has worked in a building on the street for 26 years, since he migrated from Paraíba to Rio, and knew nothing about the honoree. "No one bothers, no one ever complained. At least the name is easy to memorize."
Resident of the street, journalist Christina Martins was inspired to learn, through the reporter, about the legal action to remove the tribute to Nina Rodrigues in Maranhão. Her reflections led her to write a chronicle defending the change of street names in the neighborhood, including her own.
"Nina Rodrigues made me think: if the city is a living organism, why can't its names keep up with time?", he wrote, imagining new honorees for the neighborhood.
"It's going to be a lot of work, but it's time to update, including to remove nefarious names that don't say anything to us", says Martins to BBC News Brasil.
While the reporter was taking photos on Rua Nina Rodrigues, she was stopped by an old delivery truck. The driver, Marcílio Pereira Cruz, is from Maranhão, and was pleased to hear about the action to change the name of the Nina Rodrigues Hospital in his state.
"I think it is an unnecessary tribute. Because he is a person who does not support black people, he cannot have the support of an institution that rehabilitates people", he considers.
"Although the streets of Rio are full of tributes to the evil people of old... This is not right," he said.
Marcílio kissed his black forearm and smiled broadly: "I love my race, I love my color!"
Discover more
Watch
End of Watch




